Create an LLC

A guide to member-managed vs. manager-managed LLCs

What is the difference between a member-managed vs. manager-managed LLCs? Learn all there is to know by reading our comprehensive guide throughout our article. 

Jump to:
section

Table of Contents

As you may already know, a Limited Liability Company (LLC) is a type of business structure that offers its owners protection from personal liability. Globally, an LLC is recognized as one of the most accessible business structures that demands minimal paperwork compared to corporations. An LLC business structure provides owners with options and flexibility in managing their business. 

Furthermore, an LLC either be a single-member LLC or have multiple members. However, companies will have to file their respective articles of organization as per the state requirements. Therefore, in instances where there are multiple owners and investors, a business structure has to elect member management or manager management to overlook the businesses. 

Now, you’re probably wondering, what exactly is the difference between a member-managed and a manager-managed LLC? Well, today we are going to answer this question in detail. So, keep reading to learn more.

Member-Managed LLC

In a member-managed LLC, all shareholders take part in running the business structure. In fact, most people who have developed an LLC choose a member-management structure whereby the owners of the LLC share responsibilities for the daily operations activities. 

Additionally, most LLC companies that lack a business structure are recognized as member-managed LLCs by default. So, each owner of the LLC has a voice in making decisions and is given a voting right. However, the role allocated to the owners in member-managed LLC depends on the specifics or constituents of the operating agreement that allocate power to the business owners. Therefore, the business owners might have an equal say in day-to-day operations of the business. 

On the contrary, in member-managed LLC the power allocated to the business owners may be pro-rata depending on the level of business ownership. For example, in a member-managed LLC real estate company a co-owner with 60 percent ownership might have twice profit distributions or much more power than an owner with a 10 percent share.

Besides that, every business that has not specified its structure in the LLC operating agreement is recognized as a member-managed LLC. As a result, every business entity is recognized as an LLC agent with the authority to bond partners by making decisions, borrowing money and signing company contracts. 

With that being said, the participants in member-managed LLC or members involved must approve such decisions by a majority of votes in the business structure. Distinctly, LLC as member-manager is the appropriate business structure choice, particularly when all the business owners want to be actively engaged in the LLC activities. 

For example, if your LLC is an apparel industry, all the business owners must play different roles such as hiring employees, designing the apparel, closing and opening the shop, marketing, and launching.

Pros of Member-managed LLCs

Most LLC businesses have adopted the member-managed LLC structure due to its benefits. Let’s take a closer look at some of these advantages in more detail below.

  1. Business decision authority

One advantage is that it gives all business owners the authority to say in management decision-making. This is important as it increases the morale of the owners since they play an active role in managing the LLC. Additionally, decision-making inclusion raises work engagement and acts as a motivation. Similarly, making important decisions aids the members in uncovering creative approaches to conducting the business owners because members perform roles best.

  1. Less complicated Structure

Furthermore, another advantage is that single, or multi-member LLC management is vital for small companies since it embraces a less complicated structure. In a way, member-management LLC is essential for a small investor who aspires to claim direct responsibility and keep the company operations streamlined. This would save small companies from extreme expenses when recruiting new employees to overlook the business. Additionally, a small company is more likely to prosper since the business owners get more ambitious to expand their activities.

  1. Brick and mortar advantage 

Lastly, member-managed LLCs tend to capture the best brick and mortar. Brick and mortar refer to an outstanding choice of other in-person companies and retailers who would help run the business. Since the approach attracts the best talents, there will be positive progress. Besides that, it actively engages owners of LLC to minimize conflicts within the LLC company. This is because the business owners have an equal say, and they can democratically make decisions within the business.

Cons of Member-managed LLCs

Moreover, while member-managed LLCs have numerous benefits, this business structure isn’t without its shortcomings. Let’s take a closer look at these” 

  1. Time consumption

The structure is highly characterized by time consumption. This is because managing an LLC is fundamentally based on hard work; hence, the business owners will be doing ownership as a full-time job to ensure that the company performs. This may hinder the business owners from seeing the bigger picture of strategizing and thus make errors that may hinder development. 

  1. Decision making democracy 

Additionally, important decisions are always based on democracy; thus, before achieving the point of agreement, members may have spent a lot of time deciding on the company's future.

  1. Outsider investments are complicated 

Further, rising investments from outside investors may be complex. This is an obstacle since the company will have to drop nearly everything and devote its time seeking outside investors. Seeking investors can be challenging since investors have to examine the business and the cofounders. This can leave the company in a physical and emotional drain. The company can go broke as the members try to seek funds to support their next project.

Manager-Managed LLC

Now that we know what a member-managed LLC is, let’s take a look at what makes a manager-managed LLC different. Simply put, in a manager-managed LLC, specifically selected members can be owners, outside members, or integration of individuals assigned responsibilities of running the business. 

On some occasions, any business entity does prefer a manager-management structure. For instance, where investors want to be passive investors, and the management authority comfortably delegates duties or management responsibilities to at least one member or nonmembers. In other words, an ALLC is regarded as manager managed when the members of the LLC are silent owners. However, the passive investors will still get their equal distributions of distributions. 

Moreover, after delegating duties to specific individuals, the passive members still retain some power or authority like dissolving the company while nonmembers take part in day-to-day operations and decision-making processes. Nonetheless, in such a structure, the principal legal agent of the company is the manager who exercises decision-making on behalf of the company. 

Additionally, an LLC business can comprise one or more managers who coordinate all activities. When the manager is not a part of the powers or are nonmembers, they are recognized as professional managers. Besides, when a company consists of numerous managers and nonmembers, they act one unity as a panel of directors for the LLC.

Typically, manager managed LLC is effective in a company that has investors. Most investors are passive partners who are shareholders in the business but lack the expertise or time to manage daily routine activities. Manager-managed has the required expertise and is well versed in business practices. 

Besides this, manager management is effective in giant companies since it promotes easy decision-making, and members are allowed to focus on their expertise.

Pros of Manager-Managed LLCs

Similarly, to member-managed LLCs, manager-managed LLCs have several advantages that help a business grow. Let’s again, take a look at some of these benefits in more detail: 

  1. Attracts investors 

Firstly, it attracts investors who can help raise finances and promote the projects. This is made possible because the appointed managing members understand the business decisions and expertise on balancing bank accounts. Hence banks and other organizations can be more willing to give out loans and financial support to companies that experienced business-minded people run.

  1. Improved decision making

Additionally, management of the LLC improves decision-making and reduces time wastage. Normally, it is always challenging to get the whole members and the company to agree on the best decisions for the company. Therefore, members can be part of the membership team without making decisions. It centralizes decision-making, eliminating a situation whereby too many people try to make decisions and thus keeping the business more focused on a single mission and vision.

 Consequently, managing members allow for faster operations due to decisions by a single individual or board of directors.

  1. Great for larger businesses 

Furthermore, manager-managed LLC is vital for managing large-size businesses. Typically, a large company has a relatively high number of owners of an LLC; hence it is not possible for all members to participate in decisions for the company. 

Moreover, the manager-managed can quickly respond to changing economic conditions without seeking any guidance.

Cons of Manager Managed LLCs

Despite the advantages of a manager-managed LLC, it also has some challenges. Let’s dive a bit deeper into some of these disadvantages. 

  1. No active decision-making for investors

The first disadvantage to manager-managed LLCs is that all passive investors are not actively involved in the decision-making processes, and they have minimal voting rights, hence can result in conflict within the organization. 

  1. Complex fiduciary duties 

Additionally, the passive members need to be cautious when formulating the business structure management policies and allocating fiduciary duties to managers. As a result, this can lead to complications in management roles along with miscommunications. 

  1. Potential salary demands

Furthermore, a professional manager managed LLC may demand a large amount of salary; hence small businesses may find it challenging to sustain their needs. Similarly, manager managed LLC may lack the understanding of the business culture compared to members and owners and thus causing problems.

Final thoughts: Choosing the best approach

As you can see, it is essential to choose a vital LLC’s management structure that would work for a business entity. The LLCs management structure from a registered agent should be supported by formation documents that describe the business structure with all client’s details recorded in the law firm. 

For example, if a business comprises family owners, a manager-managed LLC is the appropriate decision to make a centralized call. Additionally, a manager-managed LLC is appropriate when the members or owners want to exercise a more passive role. Nonetheless, in large companies, manager-managed is vital since it streamlines business decisions.

On the other hand, member-managed LLC is crucial in small businesses. This is because it is easier to allocate authority among the respective members. Small businesses members will have more power and involvement in business decisions. 

Therefore, member management vs. manager management is an important concept that should be thought over in your business planning stage to ensure you company thrives long-term. 

5 Steps To Form Your LLC

1
Choose an available business name
2
Designate a registered agent
3
File all your state-required paperwork (Articles of Organization, operating agreement, etc.)
4
Get a federal tax ID (EIN) number
5
Make sure to pay all mandatory annual fees and state fees
Or, skip the above steps and let Nearside do it for you!
Form Your LLC Today
Free report and guide
How COVID-19 Impacted Incomes of the Self-Employed Workforce
How did the pandemic impact the income of  gig workers and entrepreneurs? Download to learn more.
Get The Report

More From

Frequently asked questions

No items found.

References